Patents can be the guardians of innovation, providing exclusive rights to inventors and fostering a culture of progress. They are one of the foundational components of intellectual property, serving as legal instruments granting inventors exclusive rights to their creations. With a lifespan typically spanning 20 years, patents are pivotal in encouraging innovation by offering inventors a competitive edge and a window for commercialization.

In the subject of patents, utility patents emerge as an interesting concept. Unlike design patents or plant patents, utility patents encompass a broad spectrum, aiming to protect novel processes, machines, manufactured articles, compositions of matter, and valuable improvements. Understanding the nuances of utility patents is important for innovators navigating the intellectual property landscape. As we explore the subject of utility patents, a closer look at India’s intellectual property landscape becomes imperative. The patent system followed by the U.S. offers three types of patents: Utility Patent, Design Patent, and Plant Patent. The Indian counterpart of the U.S. Utility Patent is only different in name, as we call it a patent. 

Incremental Inventions – Need for Protection as the Current System is Devoid of Protection for the Same

Not every groundbreaking idea or innovation emerges as a revolutionary leap; many find their footing through incremental inventions. These are small, yet significant improvements or modifications to existing products or processes. While these strides may lack the grandeur of a groundbreaking discovery, their cumulative impact on technological progress is undeniable.

Securing protection for such incremental inventions is crucial for several reasons. Firstly, these innovations often represent the building blocks of larger, transformative developments. Without adequate protection, innovators risk exposure to imitations, hindering the potential for further advancement.

Moreover, incremental inventions frequently arise from the continuous efforts of Small and Medium Enterprises (SMEs) and individual inventors. Unlike major corporations, SMEs may lack the resources for extensive research and development. Therefore, ensuring protection for incremental inventions becomes a lifeline for these entities, fostering an environment conducive to sustained innovation.

The existing patent system, while robust, poses challenges for incremental inventions. The stringent criteria for patentability, which demand novelty, inventive step, and industrial applicability, can be a barrier. Incremental inventions may not always meet the high threshold of inventive step, especially when compared to revolutionary breakthroughs. This gap in the system leaves a significant portion of inventive endeavours unprotected. Individual inventors and SMEs, often at the forefront of incremental innovations, face hurdles in obtaining patents due to these intricate requirements. As a result, these entities find themselves hurdled by a terrain that seems tailored for major corporations with substantial resources.

Reference to the Reports from Government Recommending Enforcement of Utility Patents

The Economic Advisory Council to the Prime Minister (EAC-PM) has recently put forth a compelling argument for the introduction of utility patents in India. In a comprehensive report authored by EAC-PM member Sanjeev Sanyal and Deputy Director Aakanksha Arora, the council advocates for a legislative framework that would grant protection to incremental innovations through the concept of “utility patents.”

This recommendation stems from a recognition of the potential of such patents to fuel innovation, particularly in Atal Tinkering Labs and Atal Incubation Centres under the Atal Innovation Mission. The report emphasises the success of this model worldwide, with three million utility patents filed globally in 2020 alone.

Utility patents, as proposed in the report, stand out for their cost-effectiveness and relaxed eligibility requirements compared to traditional patents. The envisaged legislation aims to establish utility patents as a distinct category, explicitly clarifying that it does not dilute the robustness of the existing patenting system. This strategic move aligns with India’s status as a thriving hub for startups and small-scale enterprises, presenting utility patents as an alternative, more accessible option in the realm of intellectual property.

Utility Models: A Potential Solution 

The utility model of patents presents itself as a potential solution to foster innovation, particularly in the context of incremental inventions. These models, prevalent in multiple countries, offer a unique approach to protecting inventions that may not meet the stringent criteria of traditional patents.

Utility models, often referred to as “petty patents” or “innovation patents,” provide a distinct form of intellectual property protection. Unlike traditional patents, utility models focus on incremental innovations and offer a cost-effective and faster alternative for inventors seeking protection.

Comparing utility models with traditional patents reveals a more relaxed set of eligibility requirements. While traditional patents demand a higher threshold of novelty, utility models embrace a broader spectrum of innovations. < last accessed on 02/01/2024 >

Advantages of Utility Models:

  • Cost-effective: Utility models are generally more affordable to obtain and maintain, making them accessible to a broader range of innovators.
  • Faster protection: The registration process for utility models is often quicker, providing inventors with expedited protection for their innovations.
  • Incremental innovation focus: Suited for inventions with minor improvements or innovations that may not involve a groundbreaking inventive step.

Countries like China, Japan, and South Korea have effectively leveraged utility models to promote technological advancements. By safeguarding minor inventions that may lack extensive novelty, these nations have created an environment where small-scale innovators can contribute significantly to scientific progress. In India’s pursuit of fostering innovation, exploring utility models could be a pivotal strategy.

The Need for Utility Model Protection in India

Recognizing the evolving nature of innovation and the unique challenges faced by SMEs and individual inventors, there is a compelling case for introducing utility model protection in India. This strategic proposal aligns with global Intellectual Property (IP) trends and aims to address critical gaps in the existing patent system.

This tailored approach accommodates incremental inventions, providing a streamlined and cost-effective mechanism for safeguarding intellectual creations. By proposing a legislative framework for utility models, India can create an avenue specifically designed to cater to the diverse spectrum of innovations. It stands to benefit SMEs and individual inventors in multifaceted ways. With lower costs and a simplified registration process, SMEs can protect their inventions without the financial burden associated with traditional patents. Individual inventors, often engaged in incremental innovations, gain a platform to secure their creations, fostering a conducive environment for grassroots inventiveness.

Aligning with Global IP Indices and IP Office Objectives

Embracing utility model protection aligns with India’s aspirations to strengthen its standing on international IP indices. The move not only reflects an openness to diverse forms of innovation but also positions India as a forward-thinking participant in the global intellectual property domain. Moreover, such alignment resonates with the objectives of the IP Office, emphasising inclusivity, accessibility, and responsiveness to the dynamic nature of inventive endeavours.

Addressing Challenges with Utility Models

Simplifying the registration process: A fundamental aspect of promoting utility models in India involves streamlining the registration process. By simplifying procedural complexities, the aim is to enhance accessibility, enabling inventors to navigate the system with ease. The emphasis lies on creating a user-friendly framework that encourages rather than hinders the protection of incremental innovations.

Ensuring a balance: Striking a delicate balance between protection and accessibility is crucial. While utility models offer a cost-effective option for safeguarding inventions, it is imperative to maintain a level playing field. Ensuring that the system encourages innovation without unduly restricting access will be vital to the success of utility model protection in India.

As the complexities of fostering innovation increase with time, utility models offer inclusivity, providing a tailored solution for incremental inventions. Emphasising accessibility, affordability, and global competitiveness, utility models have the potential to revolutionise India’s innovation ecosystem. This calls for ongoing discussions and thoughtful policy considerations to harness the full spectrum of possibilities utility models present in advancing India’s innovation agenda.

Divya Shekar

Branch Head - Bangalore

Write A Comment